"The government has extended sufficient corporate tax relief, but it did not translate to creation of jobs and hike in salaries, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has said," adding that, "his government had slashed the basic corporate tax rate from 30% to 22% and exempted income tax on annual salaries of up to Rs 1.2 million." NDTV. However, India has Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) law that mandates that "companies shall spend at least 2% of the average net profits of the company during the three immediately preceding financial years." Total CSR expenditure was over Rs 1.44 trillion from 2019-20 to 2023-24. pib. gov.in. "CSR spending reached Rs 407.94 billion in FY25, growing at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 15% over the past decade." Fortune. Supporting Mr Modi, Economic Affairs Secretary Anuradha Thakur told industry leaders that higher wages would stimulate demand and result in a virtuous cycle. "India's average monthly earnings for regular salaried workers advanced about 5% in years 2023 and 2024," but, adjusted for inflation earnings were flat. Inflation is hotting up again, so that "Households have increasingly turned to borrowing to support spending, adding to questions about the durability of consumption, which accounts for about 60% of gross domestic product." BS. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has a mandate to control inflation and in March 2026, "India's federal government retained its retail inflation target at 4%, within a comfort band of 2%-6%, according to an official notification." Reuters. But, except in 2025, the consumer price index (CPI) inflation has exceeded the 4% target every year since 2020. rateinflation.com. "Chief Economic Advisor V Anantha Nageswaran said, monetary policy tools such as interest rate adjustments may become less effective in tackling inflation," as "Amid persistent supply induced issues, countries will have to use all kinds of flexibilities with regards to the inflation targeting framework." DD. Which is CEA-speak for "We can't increase supplies of food and fuel, so don't increase interest rates." Which is what the RBI did when it held its interest rate at 4% for 24 months from May 2020 to May 2022 (Shriram Finance), when CPI inflation was raging at around 7%. If supplies cannot be increased, higher consumer demand, stimulated by higher earnings, will only lead to higher prices and higher inflation. India's wholesale price inflation jumped to 12.29% in October due to a rise in fuel prices (Reuters), while the CPI index increased by 6.09% year-on-year in October (pib.gov.in). "Companies across India's consumer goods, automobiles, paints and other sectors are raising prices to offset the surge in input and logistics costs triggered by the West Asia conflict. However, incomplete pass-through is squeezing operating margins, as businesses absorb part of the increase to protect demand and sales volumes." ET. Higher prices led to subdued consumer spending while lower profits restricted company expenditures. "Online festive sales have fallen short of even the industry's muted expectations, which were already tempered by rising input costs that pushed up prices across categories and left little room for discounts." FE. Industries also have to cope with whims of the government and officials. The 8th of November 2026 was the 10th anniversary of the disastrous demonetisation when Mr Modi suddenly announced the withdrawal of Rs 1000 and Rs 500 banknotes with just 4 hours notice (wikipedia), leading to a near complete stoppage of all transactions. Then there are the jobsworth officials. "India is imposing an effective duty tax of 162.5% on bulk Scotch whisky, higher than the 150% levied before the India-UK trade agreement came into force." This is apparently due to customs classification. TOI. It is true that Henry Ford doubled the wages of his workers which led to increased profits (Ebisco), but Indian business families, very wisely, are setting up "family offices in Singapore and other jurisdictions". ET. The solution is simple: Rules must be clear, not open to interpretation; must be durable; must not be changed suddenly, even by the Dear Leader; must be resolved quickly by courts and an adverse judgement must be honored by the self-important apparatchiks. 'Do as I say, and not as I do' (Wiktionary), may seem obvious to Dear Leader but not to those who have to spend their money. Money talks louder. So, who's listening.
No comments:
Post a Comment