Tuesday, May 29, 2007

India was ranked thirteenth in the world on Forbes Tax Misery and Reform Index. Lowest n the list were UAE, Qatar, Hongkong, Cyprus and Singapore. Highest were France, Belgium, China, Sweden, and Italy. Nine of the top ten places were occupied by European countries. What Forbes probably did not take into account was the returns on tax. True Europeans pay a lot of tax but they have the luxury of social services, good roads, uninterrupted electricity and clean water for twentyfour hours. Consider water. Areas in Delhi get only ten minutes' of trickle everyday. Everyone has bought large plastic tanks to collect whatever water that comes. Water pumps are then used to raise the water to another tank on the roof of the house. Water has to be bought from tankers at Rs. 100 for 1000 litres. Since the purity of water is dubious every one has a purifying system at home, charcoal filters for the poor and reverse osmosis systems for the rich. Regular power failure means everyone has a generator or invertor to run a few lights and fans. If food rots in the fridge tough luck. Voltage fluctuations result in burning of electric implements such as fridges and televisions. Broken roads wear out car tyres and broken suspensions are common. Children die regularly by falling into open manholes callously left open by municipal workers. We deserve to be first on that list. Forbes please note.

2 comments:

papa_the_great said...

Hear hear. Tax in India is ridiculous with the latest budget only increasing it. Why should the politicians give the 'aam admi' any returns from the tax when more taxes means more pocket money for themselves?

I just find it repulsive when the politicians first steal our money and then flaunt that theft in our face. No politician can afford an armada of mercedes cars and the government certainly does not provide them. They should at least have the decency to keep their black money in a sack in their basement.

The Aam Aadmi said...

Thank you Papa. Today even poor people carry mobile phones and own two wheelers. Every phone call is taxed at 12.5% and out of Rs 46, Rs. 30 is tax on petrol. Thus the aam aadmi may not be paying direct taxes but is taxed heavily indirectly. This is to keep people poor and dependent on the handouts of the politicians. After all a nation of beggars is easy to control.